

use "Regional Convergence.Krause & Zarit.Figures"







***final***
*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 6A: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 6C: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 5A: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 6B: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 6D: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 5B: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))




***Manuscript Models Sans Controls ***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.4: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==2 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-2.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



*** Manuscript Models with only Transformed Estimates ***


***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.3: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==1 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))






*** SI Models with only Non-Transformed Estimates ***


***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==11 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.2: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==11 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.4: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) || (scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==11 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-3.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



*** SI Models with only PC Squared in Income Equation ***


*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==5 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-4.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==5 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-4.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==5 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-4.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



*** SI Models with SUR Bivariate Equation Systems Model ***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.4: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==9 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-5.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Census South***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.4: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==13 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-7.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (CENSUS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))




***Confederacy South***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.4: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==14 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-8.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (CONFEDERACY)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))




***HVD, Post 1980 Only***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3A: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3B: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3C: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3D: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3E: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==12 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure 3F: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (HVD)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))





*** South Plus Missouri ***


*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.4 Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==15 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-9.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (MISSOURI)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Deep South / Peripheral South***


*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.4 Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==16 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-10.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (DEEP SOUTH)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Manuscript Models Sans Time Effects***

*** Short-Run INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.1: Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Long-Run Multiplier INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.2: Long-Term Multiplier Impact of Partisan Competition on Income (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Error Correction INC***
twoway (rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap ranneylower ranneyhigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter ranneyrinc2effect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Correction Rate of Per Capita Real State Personal Income", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.3: Equilibrium Adjustment by Income (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))



***Short-Run PC***

twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==4 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.4 Short-Term Cumulative Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))

*** Long-Run Multiplier PC***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==2 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Marginal Impact on Partisan Competition in State Legislatures", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.5: Long-Run Multiplier Impact of Income on Partisan Competition (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


*** Error Correction PC ***


twoway (rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==2, lcolor(blue) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==3, lcolor(red) lpattern(dash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==4, lcolor(dkgreen) lpattern(vshortdash) lwidth(medthick))||(rcap rinclower rinchigher period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==5, lcolor(dkorange) lpattern(longdash_shortdash) lwidth(medthick)) ||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==2, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==3, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==4, mcolor(black))||(scatter rinc2ranneyeffect period if effect==1 & model==17 & region==5, mcolor(black)), ytitle("Error Corection Rate of State Legislative Balance", size(small)) yline(0, lcolor(black)) xlabel(1 "1942 - 2010" 2 "1942 - 1980" 3 "1981 - 2010") xscale(range(0.5 3.5)) title("Figure SI-11.6: Equilibrium Adjustment by Partisan Competition (SANS TIME EFFECTS)", size(small)) legend(off) xtitle("Historical Period", height(6))


